We tested 25 popular crypto trading rules. Most didn’t work.
Before launching, we tested 25 trading rules people commonly use, from “buy the dip” to “buy what’s pumping”, plus our own trend score. 21 looked positive in both halves of the data. None was positive in every single year, and none stayed clearly above zero in every year once each coin was counted once a month. One thing did hold up every time: how much a coin swings.
Check how risky your coins are · free Explore the results in the app
How we tested
- 144 coins, daily prices from CoinGecko, September 2022 to October 2026 (about 5,000 samples).
- Each rule was compared with buying on an average day, 30 days later.
- A “strict test” removed overlapping trades, so one long move couldn’t be counted many times.
- We checked each half of the data separately and every calendar year, including the 2022 bear market.
The big claims at a glance
| Claim | Result |
|---|---|
| Buy when a coin is “oversold” | Didn’t hold up |
| Buy what’s pumping | Still testing |
| Buy coins that are beating Bitcoin | Didn’t hold up |
| Buy the dip in an uptrend | Didn’t hold up |
| Wait for the signal to confirm | Didn’t hold up |
| Calm coins go up more | Didn’t hold up |
| Our own score | Didn’t hold up |
| Volatility tells you how big the swings will be | Held up |
Buy when a coin is “oversold” · Didn’t hold up
| 30 days later, vs an average day | −1.5 pts |
| Went up within 30 days | 45% (any day: 45%) |
| Strict test (no overlapping trades) | −1.4 ± 2.3 pts |
No better than buying on a random day, slightly worse. Oversold coins often keep falling.
Buy what’s pumping · Still testing
| 30 days later, vs an average day | +6.3 pts |
| Went up within 30 days | 49% (any day: 45%) |
| Strict test (no overlapping trades) | +7.2 ± 5.0 pts |
| 2022 (bear market) | −9.1 pts |
| Worked on | 91 of 141 coins |
The strongest result we found, and it passed the strict test. But it lost 9 points in the 2022 bear market, and momentum tends to fail exactly when you most need it to work. We’re watching it in the live record before calling it.
Buy coins that are beating Bitcoin · Didn’t hold up
| 30 days later, vs an average day | +1.4 pts |
| Went up within 30 days | 40% (any day: 45%) |
| Worked on | 39 of 140 coins |
| 90-day version | +4.9 pts, but went up only 43% of the time |
A few big winners lifted the average, but most of these coins went up less often than a random pick.
Buy the dip in an uptrend · Didn’t hold up
| 30 days later, vs an average day | +1.9 pts |
| Went up within 30 days | 45% (any day: 45%) |
| Strict test (no overlapping trades) | +0.9 ± 3.1 pts, can’t tell from zero |
No measurable edge on daily crypto data. The dip often kept dipping.
Wait for the signal to confirm · Didn’t hold up
| 30 days later, vs an average day | +3.3 pts |
| Went up within 30 days | 46% (any day: 45%) |
| Strict test (no overlapping trades) | +1.0 ± 3.2 pts, can’t tell from zero |
Waiting made signals later, not clearly better.
Calm coins go up more · Didn’t hold up
| Typical (median) 30 days, calmest vs wildest group | −0.3% vs −5.0% |
| Average 30 days, calmest vs wildest group | +3.9% vs +10.5% |
| Ranked fairly, day by day | No clear winner |
This one fooled us at first. Calm coins had the better typical month, but the wild ones had the higher average because of a few huge winners. That’s a difference in how bumpy the ride is, not a reliable edge.
Our own score · Didn’t hold up
| 30 days later, vs an average day | +3.0 pts |
| Strict test (no overlapping trades) | +3.1 ± 3.4 pts, can’t tell from zero |
| Beat just holding Bitcoin | 39% of the time |
| Negative years | 2024 and 2025 |
Our score describes a coin’s trend well, and leaned positive on average, but not clearly enough to call it a forecast. We say so on every page and publish this result anyway.
Volatility tells you how big the swings will be · Held up
| Dipped 20%+ within 30 days | 15% calmest fifth → 51% wildest fifth |
| Rose 20%+ within 30 days | 25% calmest → 55% wildest |
| Average worst dip | −10.4% → −22.3% |
| Held in | Every coin-size group |
The one finding that held up. It doesn’t say which way a coin will go, only how rough the ride is likely to be. That’s what VoltX shows on every coin.
What we did with this
We built the app around the one finding that held up. VoltX rates every coin from Low Voltage to Overload by how hard it swings. It doesn’t predict direction; it tells you how rough the ride is likely to be. Our trend score is still in the app as a description of each coin’s trend, not a forecast, and every score is saved nightly so anyone can check it later on our Track Record page.
